Hu Yoshida

Don’t Confuse Magic Quadrant Positioning with Critical Capabilities Leadership For Object storage

Blog Post created by Hu Yoshida Employee on Nov 30, 2017

Gartner differentiates object storage from distributed file systems, and have published separate Critical Capabilities reports for each. The last Critical Capabilities for object storage was published March 31, 2016. In this report, written by Gartner analysts, Arun Chandrasekaran, Raj Bala and Garth Landers, Gartner recommends that readers of the report “Choose object storage products as alternatives to block and file storage when you need huge scalable capacity, reduced management overhead and lower cost of ownership.” We believe the use cases for object storage and block and file systems are quite different.


This report clearly showed Hitachi Vantara’s HCP in a leadership position for object store


Quadrant Object store.png

Then in October of 2016, Gartner combined object storage and distributed file systems into one Magic Quadrant (MQ) report, and as stated in the 2017 report, Gartner defines distributed file systems and object storage as software and hardware solutions that are based on "shared nothing architecture" and support object and/or scale-out file technology to address requirements for unstructured data growth.  However, they still recognized the difference in these two technologies in their research.


Distributed file system storage uses a single parallel file system to cluster multiple storage

nodes together, presenting a single namespace and storage pool to provide high bandwidth for

multiple hosts in parallel. Data is distributed over multiple nodes in the cluster to deliver data

availability and resilience in a self-healing manner, and to provide high throughput and

capacity linearly.”


“Object storage refers to devices and software that house data in structures called "objects," and serve clients via RESTful HTTP APIs..”



On October 17th, Gartner published their second annual " Magic Quadrant for Distributed File Systems and Object Storage." For the second year in a row, we are the only vendor in the Challengers quadrant since we were only evaluated on our HCP object storage. It is important to note that the Magic Quadrant report is NOT a stand-alone assessment of object store.  As the title states, this is a vendor-level analysis based on the COMBINATION of an Object Storage and Distributed File Systems offering.


A new Critical Capabilities for object storage is expected to be published in early 2018.  We believe that report will be a more accurate way to evaluate object storage systems. We would expect to score much higher due to the addition of geo-distributed erasure coding and other functionalities in HCP, as well as the addition of Hitachi Content Intelligence to the HCP portfolio.


Gartner, Critical Capabilities for Distributed File Systems, 09 November 2017

Gartner, Critical Capabilities for Object Storage, 31 March 2016

Gartner, Magic Quadrant for Distributed File Systems and Object Storage, 17 October 2017


Gartner does not endorse any vendor, product or service depicted in its research publications, and does not advise technology users to select only those vendors with the highest ratings or other designation. Gartner research publications consist of the opinions of Gartner's research organization and should not be construed as statements of fact. Gartner disclaims all warranties, expressed or implied, with respect to this research, including any warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose.